If you haven’t heard the recent news by now, the Red Sox claimed Brian Giles off waivers yesterday and have 48 hours to work out a possible trade to bring the veteran outfielder to Boston. The real question we have to ask ourselves is, why?
Rumor has it that Theo placed in the claim simply to deny the Angles or Rays a shot at picking up the 37-year-old. In that case, this ordeal indeed makes sense, but lets play the role of Terry Francona and say Brian Giles were to agree to come to Boston.
Defensively, the Red Sox are set in the outfield. Coco Crisp and Jacoby Ellsbury’s defense in the center field has been nothing short of superb. Jason Bay seems to have a knack for playing balls off the wall, sort of like the Sox’ old left-fielder from Washington Heights. JD Drew certainly isn’t a liability as your starting right fielder. He could be a quality bat off the bench, but do you think Brian Giles would be alright with that?
Beyond that, if we take a glance at the stat book, we see that Giles’ numbers have irrevocably diminished with age. He’ still a guy who can get on base and draw a fair share of walks, much like the Greek-God of walks, Kevin Youkilis, but the power isn’t there anymore.
From 1999-2002, a time in which baseball was still considered "The Steroid Era", Giles averaged 37 HR’s and 108 RBI’s while playing for the Pittsburgh Pirates. Over the past several years, he’s put up a total of 48 dingers in 540 games. Suspicious, isn’t it?
Just by reading these numbers alone, I start to wonder why Brian Giles wasn’t named in the Mitchell Report. The numbers don’t lie, the ‘Roid Era doesn’t lie, too.
If Giles indeed does agree to come to Boston, a couple of questions arise. Where would he play? How will he handle right field in Fenway? How comfortable will he be with reduced playing time? Amalie Benjamin of the Globe says Giles has some incentive to come to Boston , as she stated in her column today:
"But there is financial incentive for Giles to approve a trade. In addition to the $9 million he is being paid this season, he gets $2 million if he’s traded. His contract has a club option for 2009, which pays him $9 million, or $11 million if he is dealt. There is also a $3 million buyout on the option.
The money (and the chance to play for a team in a pennant race) would seem to be the big enticement for Giles to waive his no-trade clause, as it wouldn’t be playing time."
** UPDATE: As this post was coming to the close, Michael Silverman of the Boston Herald reports that Giles has nixed the trade to Boston **
C HICAGO — The Brian Giles era with the Red Sox never got started.
Giles exercised his no-trade clause earlier this afternoon, nixing the waiver claim the Red Sox had made on the 37-year-old left-handed hitter, according to a baseball source. The primary factor was family reasons, as Giles wants to remain close to his children, who live in San Diego, where Giles will remain as an outfielder.
The Red Sox put in a claim on Giles on Wednesday and had 48 hours to work out a deal with the Padres. The 48-hour window closed at 1 p.m.
—
On a side note, don’t you find it strange that players have certain clauses in their contract in which they can veto a trade involving certain teams? Boston seems to fall in that category much too often. Is it because of the pressure to play in Boston? Is it because people seem to think Boston is a racist city (a la, Barry Bonds)? It’s funny how the only contender out of the 8 teams in which Brian Giles can veto a trade to is Boston (The Rays are also on the list, but this was before they were atop the AL East. The other teams include the Pirates, the Nationals, and Orioles, to name a few.
Take all the factors into account about Giles, and I can honestly say it didn’t matter if Brian Giles came to Boston or not. But with these facts, the only true assumption we can make about Brian Giles is he’s simply a washed-up ‘roidiac.